Remortgage

Fixed vs Tracker for Your 2025 Remortgage – Which Should You Pick?

With interest rates shifting and remortgage deals changing weekly, choosing between a fixed or tracker mortgage in 2025 isn’t just about the numbers, it’s about what fits your goals, budget, and risk tolerance. In this guide, we break down the pros and cons of both options, share real examples from clients we've helped, and give you the insight you need to make the right move this year.

Will Sharman

Jun 30, 2025

UK homeowner comparing fixed vs tracker mortgage options on a laptop in 2025

Why This Choice Matters More Than Ever in 2025

With mortgage rates shifting and the base rate in motion, remortgaging in 2025 comes with one big question: Should you go fixed or tracker?
This guide breaks it down simply, using real-world insight and examples from clients we’ve helped recently at Mortgage Brokers Near Me.

2025 has already seen two base rate cuts, with the Bank of England holding the rate at 4.5% in March. Lenders are reacting quickly — tracker rates are falling, and fixed rates are becoming more competitive again.

The result? Confusion for homeowners, especially those whose fixed deals are ending or those weighing up a remortgage.

What Is a Fixed-Rate Mortgage?

A fixed-rate mortgage locks in your interest rate for a set period commonly 2, 5, or 10 years. Your monthly payments stay the same, even if the base rate changes.

Pros:

  • Predictable monthly payments
  • Protection if interest rates rise
  • Easier for budgeting

Cons:

  • You won’t benefit if rates drop
  • Can come with higher initial rates
  • Early repayment charges apply if you want to switch mid-term

Best for: Risk-averse borrowers, fixed budgets, or first-time buyers looking for stability.

Quote from Will Sharman, Mortgage Broker: “We’re seeing more clients asking, ‘Should I fix now or hold out?’ and the right answer depends entirely on your situation, risk tolerance, and budget. That’s why personalised advice is more important than ever.”

What Is a Tracker Mortgage?

A tracker mortgage follows the Bank of England base rate, usually with a small fixed margin added on top (e.g. base + 0.75%). This means your monthly payments rise or fall as the base rate changes.

Pros:

  • Lower starting rates (often)
  • You benefit from base rate cuts
  • Flexible terms and often lower ERCs

Cons:

  • Payments can increase unexpectedly
  • Budgeting is harder with rate fluctuations
  • Less predictable over long terms

Best for: Confident borrowers, short-term deals, or those expecting rates to fall further.

What Most People Are Choosing Right Now (And Why)

Most of our clients are opting for:

  • 2-year fixed deals: short-term security while waiting to see how rates shift
  • Or base rate trackers: taking advantage of the recent drops

People remortgaging right now are being cautious but many are choosing flexible options with room to switch if things improve.

Real Case: Fixed vs Tracker in Practice

In early 2024, we helped a client in Reading weighing up a remortgage decision. Their two-year fix was ending, and they were unsure whether to refix or go tracker.

They had a £300,000 mortgage, 60% LTV.

  • Tracker offer: Base + 0.74% → 4.24%
  • Fixed offer: 4.69% for 2 years

Over two years, they could save £2,160 by going tracker assuming rates don’t rise again.

Fixed vs Tracker Mortgage Rate Comparison Table (July 2025 Snapshot)

Note: Rates shown above are based on July 2025 averages and are subject to change. Use this as a guide to compare how flexibility, fees, and risk vary not just the rate.

Fixed vs Tracker Mortgage Rate Comparison Table (July 2025 Snapshot)

Should You Pick Fixed or Tracker? (Decision Flow)

Use this simple guide to help you decide:

1. Do you need predictable payments to budget each month?
Yes – A Fixed Rate Mortgage is likely the safer option. (See Section : What Is a Fixed-Rate Mortgage)
No – Consider your comfort with rate changes (see Section: What Is a Tracker Mortgage)

2. Are you comfortable with the possibility of your monthly payments increasing if rates rise?
Yes – A Tracker Mortgage could work well, especially if rates continue to fall. (See Section: What Is a Tracker Mortgage)
No – A Fixed Rate will give you peace of mind and payment stability. (See Section: What Is a Fixed-Rate Mortgage)

3. Do you believe interest rates will drop or remain low in the near future?
Yes – A Tracker Mortgage might offer short-term savings.
Not Sure – A 2-Year Fixed Deal gives you flexibility while rates settle. (See Section: What Most People Are Choosing Right Now)

Case Study – Self-Employed Remortgage Client

Earlier this year, we worked with Hassan, a freelance designer based in Birmingham. His fixed deal was ending, but as a self-employed borrower, he was worried lenders wouldn’t offer him competitive tracker options due to income fluctuations.

We reviewed his last 2 years of SA302s, checked his affordability, and compared both fixed and tracker options based on realistic earnings.

  • Fixed option: 5-year fix at 4.19%
  • Tracker option: Base +0.79% → 4.54%
  • Tracker gave more flexibility, but monthly payments varied and stress-tested higher.

In the end, Hassan chose a 2-year fixed to maintain budgeting stability and revisit his income structure before making a longer-term decision.

What Happens When Your Term Ends?

When your fixed or tracker deal ends, you’ll revert to your lender’s Standard Variable Rate (SVR) usually much higher. This can add hundreds to your monthly payment.

Key tip:
If your deal ends within the next 6 months, you can often lock in a new one early and we can help you do that without a penalty in most cases.

FAQs – Fixed vs Tracker Remortgage

Can I switch mid-term if rates drop?

Only if your deal has no ERC or very low fees. Always check the fine print.

What are average fixed and tracker rates right now (60% LTV)?

  • Fixed: ~3.89%–4.49%
  • Tracker: ~4.24%–4.44%
    (Rates change weekly — ask us for the latest live rates.)

What’s better for a remortgage fixed or tracker?

It depends on your financial situation and goals. Fixed is safer; tracker may be cheaper if rates keep falling.

Is it worth getting advice for a remortgage?

100%. A 30-minute chat with a broker could save you thousands in the long run.

Illustration comparing fixed rate and tracker rate mortgages in 2025, with a house representing fixed rates and a clipboard with a pencil representing tracker rates, divided by a bold “VS” symbol.
“We didn’t want surprises, but after talking through the options with Will, the tracker made more sense for now. Having someone break it down for us gave us the confidence to go for it.”

How Mortgage Brokers Near Me Can Help

We compare live fixed and tracker deals across dozens of lenders, including broker-only products not available direct. We’ll also:

  • Check if you’re eligible to switch early
  • Run the numbers to show your potential savings
  • Recommend the most cost-effective and flexible option

📞 Book your free remortgage review today. No pressure. Just clarity and expert guidance.

Ready to Remortgage?

Whether you want to lock in peace of mind or ride the tracker wave while rates fall, we’ll help you make the smartest choice for your situation.

Get in Contact below to get a free remortgage quote from Will and the team no obligation, just expert help.

Other Articles

Who To Trust When Buying a House?

Estate agents work for the seller, banks protect their own profits, and that leaves buyers without anyone truly on their side. A mortgage broker is the only one focused on your best interests, helping you navigate offers, avoid conflicts of interest, and keep the process moving. If you are buying a home, especially as a first-time buyer, having an expert in your corner makes the difference between overpaying and buying with confidence.

Read Article

‍Is It Worth Using a Mortgage Broker in the UK

White house toy in hand

The Ultimate Guide to Mortgage Brokers in the UK

Read Article

November 2025 Mortgage Market Update: What Buyers Should Actually Do Right Now

November 2025 Mortgage Market Update: What Buyers Should Actually Do Right Now

Mortgage rates have steadied after months of change, but affordability is still tight. The Bank of England hasn’t moved the base rate yet, and talk of a new property tax has made some buyers nervous. If you’re thinking about buying or remortgaging, the best move right now is to plan early, get advice, and focus on what you can control, not the headlines.

Read Article

Get in touch.

Whether you have questions about our services, need support, or want to share your feedback, our dedicated team is here to assist you every step of the way.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Chat IconX icon to exit
Start a conversation
What channel do you prefer?
Send a message
How can we help?
We usually reply within 24-hours.
Thank you!

Your message has been sent!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Use this window to start new conversations.